User Feedback, Is It The Only Criteria?


“Exploring Android Wear’s Usability Drawbacks and Why It Keeps Stumbling in a Fitness-Oriented Wearable Market,” an article by Daniel Marchena, Co-Host of the XDA/Android Podcast, where he explains some of the drawbacks in the usability of Android’s wearable technology. Wearable technology is a recent trend and the discussions on its usability is relatively new. Mr. Marchena focuses mostly on the Andriod Smart Watch and compares it to other items on the market such as the Apple Watch. In his review he puts a lot of priority on user feedback especially in the areas of notification control and health monitoring.

The article starts by addressing the major draw packs in financial success, or lack of, that the Smart Watch has experiences in comparison to the Apple Watch. The author notes that the success of wearable technology, outside of Fit Bits, is small compared to other areas of technology, such as Phones and Tablets. Mr. Marchena states “Even the Apple Watch had to wait a considerable amount of time – a year and a half – before becoming a “success”; and compared to the iPad and iPhone it really isn’t. Unfortunately, it is difficult to see how the smartwatch economy really shapes up in terms of market share since there are no dedicated or specific Android Wear numbers, but we do know that Apple holds over 50% of the market.” He then goes on to explain the reason people buy wearable technology in the first place noting that the need for notification control, especially in limiting the feedback that user gets from the device, is a factor in owning a wearable device;
• Peer pressure, people buy wearable technology because others buy them.
• Notification control.
• Fitness tracking and health monitoring.

For the first reason, in terms of peer pressure, the Smart Watch does well. It has the ability to accommodate a variety of styles and budgets to fit the needs of the user. If the users wants something sleek and modern Android offers that, if they want something more traditional looking Android offers that to along with a range of prices to fit the budgets of its users. Apple and Samsung on the other hand don’t offer as much in terms of style preference and budget ” If you don’t like square watches, then Apple cannot help you. If you wanted a classy polished watch, then Samsung cannot help you.” For the second reason, and Android does well in this area to. It gives the user enough control, as the author declares, “allowing you to easily reply and dismiss notifications on the fly.” Mr. Marchena acknowledges that although Andriod does well in these two areas it fails because it doesn’t give the user a reason to continue wearing it. “That all comes down to the final reason; while Android Wear offers good and affordable devices to purchase, and offers a great notification experience, it offers little to no reason to continue using its wearables. It wasn’t until the Apple Watch came along that I knew just how bad Android Wear was at offering a compelling reason to continue wearing a watch daily; health and fitness tracking.”


“[Apple] Activity” tracks your active calories, counts your steps, monitors your standing hours and gives you a feedback of your exercise activity, like many other “fitness” applications. It also is always monitoring your heart rate and uses this information to provide timely feedback about how you are doing. All of this information is also seamlessly fed back into a zero impact application, Apple Health, which allows you to see a total overview your healthiness.” This was the overall reason why the Smart Watch wasn’t ranked as highly or considered to do as well as its competitors.

Personally I think user feedback is extremely important especially when it gives the user control over what feedback they receive. However I do not feel that in this case that feedback should considered over the major functionality of the technology. If the Smart Watch is more accessible then it has the ability to reach more people and should be considered a much more obtainable product. In terms of design it seems to have a range of options that can cater to a user’s style. I will note that if a product doesn’t fulfill the major reason why someone has brought it then it is a faulty design, however in this case functionality should be given higher priority. The functionality is not solely based on the health aspects of the Smart Watch because, in my opinion, if someone wanted something to act solely as a Fit Bit they would have brought one. If someone buys a Smart Watch they want it not only for the health tracking aspects but for its other features as well. Although the article is fitness orientated, I will state again that the accessibility of fitness devices should be higher priority.  Smart Watch may not be doing as well as the Apple Watch but that can be due to another combination of reasons. I think that although this article gives good information about the area of wearable technologies and gives good reason for why feedback is important it should note that feedback isn’t the only design criteria.



Marchena, Daniel.(2017). Exploring Android Wear’s Usability Drawbacks and Why It
Keeps Stumbling in a Fitness-Oriented Wearable Market.Xda-developer. Retrieved from

Design Critique: Etsy Website


Etsy is an online marketplace where people can set up digital shops and sell custom and self-made items. This critique is based on the customer’s perspective of purchasing an item through Etsy and is based on the online website and will not take into consideration the mobile app. This critique will review specifically the search page, item page, and shop page.

Etsy Critiques
Search Page: Easy to use search system with a good range of refinement tools but could benefit from moving recommend shops higher on the page for better discoverability.

Item Page: Good signifiers that inform the shopper that their item is within the cart. Also uses good mapping to avoid confusion with their multiple range of options. Would be improved with displaying only the featured item in the review section.

Shop Page: Good discoverability of shop options and seller information but could benefit from moving the custom order button higher up with the contact seller button.

First, the discoverability of the search engine is easy and requires no though or searching since it is the first thing that customers see when accessing the website. Here customers can search for keywords, items, and shop names. Searching for something as simple and vague as “love” can yield a variety of results which Etsy allows the customer to break down further to find the item they want. Customers can narrow their searches with recommended categories at the top of the page refine their searches through an easy to see and easy to use bar on the left which are clearly labeled and are a good signifier of their uses. Refining allows the customer to find items based on price range, color, shop location, item type, ordering options, and shipping options. The search refinements are all placed together on one side next to the displayed items which is good mapping since that is where customers would expect to see it. When selecting the refinement option, such as color, only the items within the color range are shown which is good feedback. One thing that might be a problem is the discoverability of recommended shops which is listed all the way at the end of the page in small blue print that matches the color of the related items. This might cause customers to skip over shops that they might enjoy and the recommended shops should be moved to the top of the page where customers can see it. Customers who have already used Etsy and have this knowledge, knowledge in the head, would know to look down there but new customers might miss it.

Once customers have selected an item they can look over the item description, reviews, store policy, and purchasing options. As well as favorite the item, like it to social media, or visit the shop page. All options are well displayed and easy to discover and well labeled to signify their use. This page also has good mapping where all related information is placed together and where customers would expect to find them. All information related to purchasing the item, such as price, gift card acceptation, number or items being shipped (which is useful in cases where items come with multiple parts), and shipping options are all located in one place at the top right next to the item. All information related to the description of the item, reviews of the item, or store policies are located together under the item.

This page also has good constraints where a customer cannot leave a review for items they haven’t purchased. If the customer chooses to add the item to their cart the cart icon immediately displays the new number of items in the cart which sends good feedback to the customer that their request has been confirmed. One problem with the item page is the review section. This section not only gives reviews for the item featured on the page but also of other items that the seller has made. Although it includes a picture in the review this can still be confusing if the seller has many items that look alike. The solution would be to feature only the reviews for the item item displayed on the page.


On the shop page customers can view other items made by the seller, see reviews, look at updates, learn about the shop, and view store policies. They can also search specific categories within the shop, contact the seller, ask a question, request a custom order, or report the shop to Etsy if there is a problem. The discoverability of the options are clear, options are organized and signify their purpose well. The mapping on this page could be better enhanced by moving the request custom order button to the top right of the screen with the contact seller button.Although the custom order button is next to a second contact seller button lower on the page, new customers wanting a custom order may click the first contact seller button without scrolling further down. This may create a problem with the feedback that customers receive. There is nothing that stops a customer for requesting a custom order within the question box so moving it also solves the problem of bad constraints and bad affordances. Overall Etsy is a good website that allows creative people to display their talents and allows customers to support artist and small businesses. When it comes to design and business one aspect, as explained by author Don Norman in his book The Design of Everyday Things is that people grow tired or item quickly even if they are designed well. He states “The problem is that after the product has been available for a while, a number of factors inevitably appear, pushing the company toward the addition of new features— toward creeping featurism.” Etsy avoids this by giving power to the sellers where they can post new products and items on a conveniently located update page. It also allows them to receive reviews for their items and create better items, taking much of the pressure improve off of the website and placing it onto the shop owners. In terms of the website design Etsy has come very far and can make use of these small listed improvements.